Whether you have actively chosen to have a baby alone because “Mr Right” just didn’t turn up or find yourself in this situation unexpectedly when he turned out to be Mr Wrong, it is essential you know where you stand from a legal perspective. Does the father have to pay child support, and do they have any rights to see the child are just two questions amongst many that can arise? In this article, we provide the answers and much more.
Donor conception
If a child has been conceived through donor artificial insemination or the transfer of an embryo via a licensed fertility clinic, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 2008 dictate who the legal parents will be. If you give birth to a child, you are the legal mother and have:
- The duty to register the birth and be recorded as the mother on the child’s birth certificate
- Parental responsibility – the legal right to make and be involved in decisions about the child’s care, including giving medical consent, and making decisions about education, religion, etc
- Financial responsibility – the duty to provide for your child, including paying maintenance if they do not live with you
- Status rights – having a lifelong mother/child connection for the purposes of things such as British nationality and inheritance and pension rights.
The law protects sperm donors so that they cannot be held legally or financially responsible for any child conceived as a result of their donation. However, these rules only apply in two very specific circumstances:
- Where the child already has two legal parents; or
- Where the donor registers with a UK fertility clinic and donates to an unknown recipient
For cases that fall outside this, a donor may be considered to be the legal father of the child. This is most commonly the case if known donation takes place via home insemination to a single mother.
Home/known donor conception
This is more complicated than donor conception via a fertility clinic and can pose problems in the future for both parties. Known donation arrangements cover a wide range of different personal circumstances, in some cases a sperm donor is a friend, but in others it could be someone the recipient has matched with specifically for the purpose of conceiving a child, such as via a matching website or agency.
The donor might intend to have a very limited role in the child’s life, or might play a more significant role. Whatever the situation, a known donor is generally not considered a “co-parent” – someone who intends to act as a fully involved parent in the child’s life.
If you are planning a home/known donor conception, it is important to set out your expectations regarding their level of involvement, and payment of child maintenance, for example. Disputes in known donation cases commonly stem from underlying mismatched expectations, so you should not rush into trying to conceive, but take your time to discuss the roles you each intend to have.
Who are the legal parents on a child conceived through known donation?
The parent who gives birth will always be the child’s legal mother and will be registered on the birth certificate. A known sperm donor will NOT be the legal father if:
- The recipients of the donation are a couple and are both the legal parents of the child; and/or
- The donor donates through a UK licensed fertility clinic and signs the correct documentation to donate to someone else with no intention of being a parent himself
If the donor is not the legal father, no financial claims can be made against him, or his estate, and it will not be possible to record his name on the child’s birth certificate.
In other donor situations not covered above, the donor will or may be the legal father. This is most commonly the case where the recipient is a single woman, and the conception takes place through home insemination. Here, the donor may be potentially vulnerable to financial claims during his lifetime and on death, regardless of whether or not he is registered on the birth certificate. It will also be possible to name the father on the child’s birth certificate providing he and the mother both agree but doing so is a significant decision since it will give the donor shared parental responsibility and the right to be involved in all decisions about the child.
What is the legal position regarding parentage following a “one-night stand”/casual sex?
If you find yourself pregnant following a one-night stand, it is your decision, and yours alone, to decide what to do. As stated above, the mother will have parental responsibility from birth, however if you are not married to the father, they will only acquire it if they are present when the birth is registered, or at some later date by agreement or court order.
Even though the pregnancy was unintended, the father will still have certain obligations, such as paying child maintenance. From a legal perspective, there is no difference between a baby conceived within a committed relationship or through casual sex, and the father will have a financial obligation to support the child until they are 18 years old. Even if they weren’t aware of the child’s existence until much later, don’t have parental responsibility or are not named on the birth certificate. If the Child Maintenance Service (CMS) becomes involved, if there is a dispute as to parentage, they may consider paternity testing by way of a DNA test to prove paternity.
Even if the child’s father is not named on the birth certificate or has parental responsibility for them, they can still potentially make an application to court seeking contact with the child. If the child’s paternal grandparents wish to have contact and you disagree, they would first need to get permission from the court to make their application.
As with any children dispute, the court’s paramount consideration is the child’s welfare and best interests. In practice, there are huge variations in outcome in such cases because such a great deal depends on the unique facts of the case.
Related Articles
Load More