Divorce proceedings can sometimes affect business ownership as the court strives to ensure a fair division of matrimonial assets. So for individuals who own a business, this may raise questions about whether they could lose part of their business in a divorce. This article will examine the risks and the options available to business-owning spouses.
Divorce and division of assets
When a marriage breaks down, the court aims to divide assets in a way that is “fair and reasonable” based on factors such as the length of the marriage, financial needs, and contributions of both parties. All assets owned by either spouse—acquired during or, in some cases, before the marriage—may be considered matrimonial property subject to division within a divorce. This includes business interests, which can be treated as assets and could potentially be divided between spouses.
Types of business ownership and divorce risk
The way a business is treated in a divorce varies depending on its structure. Each business type has unique implications in divorce proceedings, and understanding these can help mitigate risks.
Sole trader
As a sole trader, the business and its assets are legally inseparable from the individual owner. In a divorce, the court can view the business as part of the owner’s personal assets and thus eligible for division. While this doesn’t necessarily mean that the non-owning spouse will gain control of half the business, they may be entitled to a share of its value.
For instance, if the business is valued during divorce proceedings and determined to have substantial value, the non-owning spouse might receive a financial award to balance the division. In cases where the sole trader cannot pay the spouse’s share, there could be pressure to sell part or all of the business, which could significantly disrupt operations.
Partnerships
In a partnership, the ownership of the business is shared among partners, and each partner has a stake in the business. While a partnership agreement might dictate how assets are distributed upon dissolution, in a divorce, a spouse’s share in the partnership can still be treated as an asset subject to division.
If a partner is going through a divorce, the court may assess the value of their share and potentially require them to compensate their spouse for their entitlement. This could place strain on the business if capital is required to make the payment, or if other partners are forced to adjust their financial contributions to maintain business stability. A well-structured partnership agreement can provide a degree of protection, for example, by preventing the sale or transfer of partnership shares without the unanimous agreement of all partners.
Limited company (Ltd)
A limited company (Ltd) is a separate legal entity from its owners, typically offering some protection to business owners in divorce proceedings. However, shares in the company are still considered assets and may be divided in a divorce. In this case, the court may assess the value of the shares owned by the spouse and potentially award a portion to the other.
This does not mean the non-owning spouse gains control of the business; they may be entitled to the value of the shares. To protect the business, the owning spouse could negotiate to retain full ownership by offering other assets in place of the shares, like cash or property.
Additionally, if there are other directors, divorce proceedings can impact them as well. They may worry about the stability of the business if shares are divided or the owning spouse’s role in the business is affected.
How are businesses valued in divorce?
To divide assets fairly, the court will assess the value of the business, often through an independent valuation. This valuation can consider various factors, including the business’s profitability, assets, liabilities, and potential growth. For limited companies, shares are assessed, while for sole traders or partnerships, an evaluation of the entire business’s worth may be undertaken.
This valuation process can be complex and expensive, and the business-owning spouse should be prepared to provide transparent financial documentation. The court may consider not only the present value but also the future earning potential, meaning a successful business may carry a higher liability in a divorce.
What are the risks to the business and other directors?
The potential risks to a business in divorce proceedings depend on the type of business, the size of the financial award required, and the degree to which the business contributes to the couple’s marital assets. Key risks include:
- Financial strain: If a substantial financial settlement is required, the business owner may be forced to draw on business assets or even sell part of the business, which could jeopardise operations.
- Disruption to management: Divorce proceedings can affect business operations, especially if one spouse plays a crucial role in management. This can disrupt decision-making processes and impact other directors or partners.
- Impact on business value: The valuation process and possible requirement to provide financial information can affect the perceived value of the business, particularly if it is a public or investor-dependent company.
What are the options for business owners in a divorce?
Business owners facing divorce have several strategies and options for protecting their interests, depending on the specific circumstances:
- Prenuptial and postnuptial agreements: These agreements can predetermine the division of assets, including business interests, in the event of a divorce. While not automatically legally binding, courts generally respect them, provided they are fair and both parties received independent legal advice.
- Negotiate asset offsetting: The business owner can negotiate to keep full control of the business by offering other marital assets to their spouse in place of the business value. This could involve transferring property, savings, or other assets to the spouse to balance the division.
- Divorce-specific shareholder agreements: For limited companies, a shareholder agreement can outline what will happen to shares in the event of a divorce. For instance, it could stipulate that shares must be sold back to the company or other shareholders before being transferred to a non-owner spouse.
- Staged financial settlement: where an immediate payout isn’t feasible, the court may allow a staged financial settlement, where the business owner pays their spouse in instalments. This approach can prevent sudden financial strain and protect the business from liquidation.
- Trusts or other legal structures: Some business owners use trusts to separate personal and business assets, potentially shielding the business from being viewed as a divisible matrimonial asset. This approach requires careful planning and may not be effective in all cases.
Seeking professional advice from family law specialists, financial advisors, and business consultants is essential to protecting business interests in the event of divorce. With proper planning and negotiation, it is often possible for business owners to retain control and preserve the value of their business, even through the difficult process of divorce.
Related Articles
Load More